When the dream wakes up: Why is El Salvador, which embraces Bitcoin, getting poorer? | Bee Network
Sumber asli: The Economist
Disusun oleh Odaily Planet Daily ( @OdailyChina )
Penerjemah: CryptoLeo ( @LeoAndCrypto )
During the recent market decline, El Salvador increased its holdings of 7 and 5 BTC on February 25 and March 4, respectively, after reaching a $1.4 billion loan bailout agreement with the IMF. According to the agreement, the IMF has imposed regulatory restrictions on the current state of kriptocurrencies in El Salvador due to concerns about the high risk of BTC, but this has not stopped El Salvador from buying BTC. In fact, the IMFs concerns are unfounded. Since President Nayib Bukele took office, his obsession with cryptocurrencies and various support measures have not improved El Salvadors economy, and have even increased the deficit. Since the implementation of the presidents crypto policy, El Salvadors deficit in crypto alone has also increased.
The Economist wrote an article about El Salvador’s journey towards crypto, which Odaily compiled below:
El Salvador has been on the brink of default for much of the period since Nayib Bukele assumed the presidency in 2019. High debt and interest payments, exacerbated by a large fiscal deficit, have been long-standing warning signs for the country’s economy. Low dollar reserves, weak investment and GDP growth, and stalled bailout talks with the International Monetary Fund have all contributed to the country’s economic recovery. Bukele’s relentless attacks on the judiciary, opponents, and the media have not done much to inspire the country.
Bukele is too obsessed with cryptocurrencies. In 2021, El Salvador became the first country to adopt Bitcoin as legal tender alongside the U.S. dollar. President Bukele has vowed to eschew traditional capital markets and raise billions of dollars through tokenized blockchain bonds. He will buy $500 million worth of Bitcoin, build a Bitcoin City, and develop geothermal energy to power Bitcoin miners. But traditional markets didnt buy it. In the summer of 2022, several Salvadoran bonds traded for an average of less than 30 cents, when the government began to postpone public sector wages to ensure cash was sufficient and investors prepared for the worst.
Unexpectedly, on February 26, the IMF board approved a $1.4 billion bailout loan, agreed in December after years of delays, to be disbursed over 40 months. To get the money, El Salvador made the usual promises of fiscal discipline—scaling down its cryptocurrency program. After a legal change in January, taxpayers are no longer paid in Bitcoin, and the private sector is allowed to accept Bitcoin payments on a voluntary basis.
El Salvador has shown a resolute resolve to repay its debts as it seeks a debt deal with the IMF. In part because of Bukele’s desire to surprise Wall Street skeptics, the country’s bond prices have risen all the way back to par, and officials have used scarce dollars to buy back bonds at a deep discount, saving a large portion of future principal payments. The fiscal deficit, which rose to 10% of GDP in 2020, has returned to pre-pandemic levels of 2-3%, roughly in line with other countries. A crackdown on tax evasion, strong remittance inflows and a slight economic recovery have boosted government revenues; energy subsidies and the phasing out of pandemic-era programs have slowed spending.
The loan reduces the risk of a debt default crisis, but El Salvador would be better off if it can get another $2.1 billion from other multilateral lenders, as hoped. Despite the deficit cuts, the country may not be able to hold out for much longer. With high debt and slow economic growth, it is unsustainable for El Salvador to continue raising funds at a 12% rate, as it did in early 2024. In dollarized economies like El Salvador, a sovereign debt default is more costly because there is no lender of last resort to avoid bank runs or contagion. Local bank deposits are partly backed by government debt, so a default could snowball into a banking crisis or even lead to de-dollarization.
As for El Salvador’s concessions on Bitcoin adoption, it may be a blessing in disguise, more of a blessing than a concession. Bukele touts cryptocurrencies as offering financial services to the two-thirds of unbanked adults and lowering the cost of remittances, which make up almost a quarter of the country’s GDP, but the main barriers to crypto financial inclusion are the size of its economy and low digital literacy, which is expensive because Salvadorans prefer to transact in paper money, an expensive business in itself, made even more expensive by crime. El Salvador’s government also rushed to launch the Chivo digital wallet, which allows payments in both U.S. dollars and Bitcoin. But the reality after the wallet’s launch has been less than ideal, with vulnerabilities and identity theft rampant — in order to steal the $30 Bitcoin reward for signing up for the wallet.
The IMF was wary of lending to El Salvador when Bitcoin was still El Salvadors legal tender. Bitcoin price volatility poses risks to financial and fiscal stability. Bitcoin can be used for money laundering and other criminal activities. The IMF said El Salvador will restrict Bitcoin transactions and purchases. According to on-chain data, the country has actually been buying Bitcoin since the agreement was reached, but it may have to reduce or reverse these purchases in order to comply with the loan agreement. El Salvador now holds 6,100 Bitcoins, worth more than $500 million, with a floating profit of about $200 million , which is also a point of pride for Bukele.
The profits may seem huge, but the costs of cryptocurrencies in El Salvador are greater than the benefits. Bukele’s crypto promotion is popular, but the volume of crypto investment and crypto tourism is small, and the benefits of financial inclusion and more efficient payment methods are negligible. In short, cryptocurrencies have never really caught on in El Salvador. In 2022, when the hype was at its peak, a CID-Gallup survey found that only one in five companies accepted Bitcoin and only 5% of taxes were paid in cryptocurrencies. The recent data may be lower, as Salvadorans still strongly prefer cash and payment cards.
In addition, rating agency Moodys said that El Salvador spent a total of $375 million on crypto experiments – including the launch of Chivo, subsidized transaction fees, Bitcoin ATMs, etc., which far exceeds the profits of its current Bitcoin holdings, and these profits are still likely to decrease as Bitcoin falls. Bukeles crypto experiment delayed El Salvadors loan agreement with the IMF, leaving El Salvadors risk premium high and his country on the verge of debt default.
But Bukele’s approval ratings are sky-high, often above 90%. He calls himself “the world’s most popular dictator,” not because of his advocacy of crypto, but because of his tough crackdown on crime, which ignores due process and the rights of suspects. His obsession with crypto has done little to alleviate El Salvador’s economic woes. While Bitcoin may remain a reserve asset on the state’s balance sheet, its days as El Salvador’s legal tender are over. Bukele is just a crypto utopian whose wild ideas have crumbled when they collided with reality.
This article is sourced from the internet: When the dream wakes up: Why is El Salvador, which embraces Bitcoin, getting poorer? Related: What To Expect From Hedera (HBAR) in March 2025 Hedera (HBAR) has recently experienced a challenging month, with its price suffering a significant downtrend. The altcoin saw substantial losses, leaving investors concerned about its future. However, a notable shift in the market suggests that HBAR may be poised for a reversal rally in March 2025. HBAR Is Back In The Bullish Zone For the first time since late January, the relative strength index (RSI) for HBAR has entered the bullish zone, signaling an important shift in sentiment. This marks a major achievement for the token, as it indicates that bullish momentum is now gaining traction. The RSI suggests that the recent downtrend may be over, and the altcoin could continue to move upward as broader market conditions improve. Investor sentiment is also improving, driven by this change in the… Analisis ## bitcoin# kriptoDefinisi #Pasar ## Tanda© 版权声明Array 上一篇 The crossroads of the crypto market: political compliance or free and open source? 下一篇 Political manifesto or paid advertising? Analyzing the real possibility of cryptocurrency strategic reserves 相关文章 BitMEX Alpha: Trader Weekly Report (12.21-12.27) 6086cf14eb90bc67ca4fc62b 38,986 3 Official platforms emerge, what concepts are being hyped in the post-Pump era? 6086cf14eb90bc67ca4fc62b 26,702 2 Bitwise Chief Investment Officer: Three major opportunities I see from the SEC’s “Project Crypto”Recommended Articles 6086cf14eb90bc67ca4fc62b 23,234 1 Hashrate hegemony escalates: Following the attack on Monero, Qubic targets DogecoinRecommended Articles 6086cf14eb90bc67ca4fc62b 24,860 1 Matrixport Research: Bitcoin Falls into Bear Market Territory, Could a Weakening Dollar Become the Next Pivot? 6086cf14eb90bc67ca4fc62b 8,121 6 CoinW Research Institute: U.S. stock tokens are launched, Robinhood reshapes the crypto financial landscape 6086cf14eb90bc67ca4fc62b 29,715 1 1 komentar Anda harus login untuk meninggalkan komentar! Segera masuk #BeelieverTYRDVMI Tamu “If you’ve lost money fraudulently to any company, broker, or account manager and want to retrieve it, contact www.Bsbforensic.com They helped me recover my funds!” 12bln lalu artikel Terbaru Did Jane Street “Manipulate” BTC? Decoding the AP System, Understanding the Power Struggle Behind ETF Creation and Redemption Pricing 2 jam yang lalu 167 Stop Comparing Bitcoin to Gold—It’s Now a High-Volatility Software Stock 2 jam yang lalu 216 Matrixport Research: $25 Billion Gamma Unwinding Imminent, Liquidity Yet to Return Behind the Rebound 2 jam yang lalu 201 ERC-5564: Ethereum’s Stealth Era Has Arrived, Receiving Addresses No Longer ‘Exposed’ 2 jam yang lalu 225 Hong Kong Regulatory Green Light: Asseto Enables DL Holdings to Achieve Compliance for Two RWA Business Implementations 2 jam yang lalu 201 Situs Web PopulerTempoLighterGAIBGliderPlanckRaylsBCPokerVooi Bee.com Portal Web3 terbesar di dunia Mitra KoinCarp binance KoinMarketCap KoinGecko hidup koin Armor Unduh Aplikasi Bee Network dan mulai perjalanan web3 Kertas putih Peran Pertanyaan Umum © 2021-2026. Semua Hak Cipta Dilindungi Undang-Undang. Kebijakan pribadi | Ketentuan Layanan Unduh Aplikasi Jaringan Lebah dan memulai perjalanan web3 Portal Web3 terbesar di dunia Mitra CoinCarp Binance CoinMarketCap CoinGecko Coinlive Armors Kertas putih Peran Pertanyaan Umum © 2021-2026. Semua Hak Cipta Dilindungi Undang-Undang. Kebijakan pribadi | Ketentuan Layanan Mencari MencariDi dalam SitusDi RantaiSosialBerita 热门推荐: Pemburu Airdrop Analisis data Selebriti Kripto Detektor Perangkap Bahasa Indonesia English 繁體中文 简体中文 日本語 Tiếng Việt العربية 한국어 हिन्दी اردو Русский Bahasa Indonesia智能索引记录
-
2026-03-02 12:16:33
综合导航
成功
标题:CHA022 - StrongShop
简介:Item Name : CHA022 Description : PINK QUARTZ FOX CHARM P
-
2026-03-02 12:14:55
图片素材
成功
标题:走过的作文400字 描写走过的作文 关于走过的作文-作文网
简介:作文网精选关于走过的400字作文,包含走过的作文素材,关于走过的作文题目,以走过为话题的400字作文大全,作文网原创名师
-
2026-03-02 12:28:03
综合导航
成功
标题:iPhone - Apple
简介:Designed for Apple Intelligence. Discover iPhone 17 Pro, iPh
-
2026-03-02 12:13:34
电商商城
成功
标题:Ni8网联科技-深圳专业网站建设、软件定制、小程序开发、物联网开发公司-深圳市网联信息科技开发有限公司
简介:网联科技是深圳专业的网站制作外包公司提供品牌网站制作商城网站开发小程序开发软件定制开发,20年来为2万多家企业打造高品牌
-
2026-03-02 12:16:59
综合导航
成功
标题:东莞市赢泰通智能装备有限公司
简介:东莞市东莞市赢泰通智能装备有限公司有限公司_东方马达、日本和泉一级代理,专业销售日本东方马达(oriental moto
-
2026-03-02 12:23:05
教育培训
成功
标题:(必备)《让》作文500字8篇
简介:在学习、工作乃至生活中,大家总免不了要接触或使用作文吧,写作文可以锻炼我们的独处习惯,让自己的心静下来,思考自己未来的方
-
2026-03-02 12:25:47
教育培训
成功
标题:二年级秋天作文必备【2篇】
简介:无论在学习、工作或是生活中,大家都经常看到作文的身影吧,作文是通过文字来表达一个主题意义的记叙方法。写起作文来就毫无头绪
-
2026-03-02 12:20:54
教育培训
成功
标题:一件小事的小学作文
简介:在平时的学习、工作或生活中,大家总少不了接触作文吧,作文是由文字组成,经过人的思想考虑,通过语言组织来表达一个主题意义的
-
2026-03-02 12:25:00
教育培训
成功
标题:★我敬佩的一个人作文
简介:在日常生活或是工作学习中,大家总免不了要接触或使用作文吧,作文是人们以书面形式表情达意的言语活动。如何写一篇有思想、有文
-
2026-03-02 12:11:21
综合导航
成功
标题:Cembrit Blunn Ltd & Anr v Apex Roofing Services LLP & Anr - 5RB Barristers
简介:Cembrit Blunn Ltd & Anr v Apex Roofing Services LLP & Anr -
-
2026-03-02 12:11:27
综合导航
成功
标题:Flaghouse Contact Information - PR.com
简介:View Flaghouse's contact information in their PR.com co
-
2026-03-02 12:24:58
图片素材
成功
标题:师恩的作文600字 描写师恩的作文 关于师恩的作文-作文网
简介:作文网精选关于师恩的600字作文,包含师恩的作文素材,关于师恩的作文题目,以师恩为话题的600字作文大全,作文网原创名师
-
2026-03-02 12:25:41
综合导航
成功
标题:Longview Mayor Spencer Boudreau Plans to Remove Charlie Kirk Way Proposal—Classic Hits 100.7 KLOG News - Classic Hits 100.7 KLOG
简介:100.7 KLOG - Classic Hits, Local News and Sports
-
2026-03-02 12:19:58
综合导航
成功
标题:How hh2 Integrates with Sage 100
简介:Streamline construction project management and financial pro
-
2026-03-02 12:29:21
综合导航
成功
标题:Tjenesteopdateringer
简介:Tjenesteopdateringer
-
2026-03-02 12:21:42
汽车交通
成功
标题:买车什么牌子的质量比较好?现在质量最好的汽车品牌型号推荐 - 购车养车 - 34楼
简介:买车时,汽车质量是绕不开的重要考量因素。一辆质量好的车,不仅能减少维修烦恼,还能在长期使用中带来更好的体验和更高的性价比
-
2026-03-02 12:30:13
综合导航
成功
标题:502019-0005 Tube Insulator
简介:The 502019-0005 Polyimide Insulator Heater Jacket Kit is des
-
2026-03-02 12:25:38
综合导航
成功
标题:Futureproofing the Workforce with AI and Analytics ICF
简介:How can organizations use emerging tech like AI and data sci
-
2026-03-02 12:19:20
电商商城
成功
标题:祛痘痘膏预订订购价格 - 京东
简介:京东是国内专业的祛痘痘膏网上购物商城,本频道提供祛痘痘膏商品预订订购价格,祛痘痘膏哪款好信息,为您选购祛痘痘膏提供全方位
-
2026-03-02 12:26:08
综合导航
成功
标题:Thrasher Logo Skate Duffle Bag - Black – CCS
简介:Color:Black
-
2026-03-02 12:28:10
数码科技
成功
标题:东方华达机电招聘_湖北东方华达机电科技有限公司招聘_电话_地址 _【官方】
简介:东方华达机电招聘,湖北东方华达机电科技有限公司招聘,公司在襄阳市樊城区中原西路如日电气院内1号厂房,招聘岗位详情。
-
2026-03-02 12:29:43
综合导航
成功
标题:原来友谊一直都在_800字_作文网
简介:往事如歌,在人生的旅途中,尽管有过坎坷,有过遗憾,却没有失去青春的美丽。相信自己,希望总是有的,让我们记住那句话:错过了
-
2026-03-02 12:21:42
教育培训
成功
标题:[必备]初中生作文
简介:在日常的学习、工作、生活中,大家都尝试过写作文吧,通过作文可以把我们那些零零散散的思想,聚集在一块。那么问题来了,到底应
-
2026-03-02 12:25:56
综合导航
成功
标题:我家的那棵“不老松”_650字_作文网
简介:亭亭山上松,瑟瑟谷中风。风声一何盛,松枝一何劲。 松树是如此的刚劲,再猛烈的风霜也吹不跨它。我家就有一棵这样的 不老松
-
2026-03-02 12:16:21
综合导航
成功
标题:Building Intimacy Press Releases & News - PR.com
简介:View press releases and news from Building Intimacy.
-
2026-03-02 12:14:56
博客创作
成功
标题:春节随笔_900字_作文网
简介:又是一年芳华。 似水流年,蹉跎了一季又一季的桃红柳绿。今岁,再见火树银花,春节在人们的翘首期盼中,迈着轻盈的步伐来到了人
-
2026-03-02 12:11:43
综合导航
成功
标题:“新大众文艺的‘在场’力量”活动在京举办-新华网
简介:“新大众文艺的‘在场’力量”活动在京举办-
-
2026-03-02 12:16:37
综合导航
成功
标题:Cook'n Order Assistant
简介:Cook
-
2026-03-02 12:30:07
综合导航
成功
标题:浦东/静安/松江/虹口/杨浦/普陀初三一模试卷&答案下载(持续更新)-上海新王牌
简介:这几天初三一模考陆续进行,王牌君搜集了各区的试卷+答案,有需要的可以扫码添加王牌君领取完整版PDF。初三一模试卷答案,上
-
2026-03-02 12:14:05
教育培训
成功
标题:[优选]礼物作文300字7篇
简介:在学习、工作或生活中,大家一定都接触过作文吧,作文是经过人的思想考虑和语言组织,通过文字来表达一个主题意义的记叙方法。那