The year 2025 is destined to be a year repeatedly scrutinized by تشفير investors and practitioners.
This year, the market accelerated the concentrated liquidation of financing illusions and narrative bubbles, beginning to shift from speculation-driven false prosperity to a value-based clearing of existing stock.
As the illusion of liquidity faded, once high-flying pioneers fell one after another. In the throes of this life-or-death struggle, the industry forced every participant to re-examine the rules of survival here.
2025 Project “Death” Profile: From Narrative Clearing to Logical JudgmentOn December 30, the RootData platform updated a list of dead crypto projects for 2025. These projects have either announced a halt in operations, declared bankruptcy, or have been deemed “dead” due to their websites being unusable for an extended period. The list is still being updated.
مصدر: RootData
Looking back at past data, the market was still in the early stages of a bull run in 2021, with hidden risks, recording 67 failure cases. Subsequently, in 2022 and 2023, triggered by the deep-water chain reactions from black swan events like the FTX collapse and the Luna crash, the number of failed projects soared to 250 and 230, respectively. In 2024, as the market gradually stabilized, the failure rate dropped back to 171.
Unlike the passive deaths caused by sudden collapses in the past, the current wave of failures points more to the collapse of business logic under extreme pressure, and is highly concentrated in hot sectors that were once heavily invested in by capital.
Specifically, the GameFi sector was the hardest hit, with a large number of projects including COMBO, Nyan Heroes, and Ember Sword shutting down one after another. The NFT sector was also devastated, with once highly-focused platforms like Royal, RECUR, and X2Y2 on the list.
Furthermore, competition at the infrastructure level has become increasingly brutal. Projects like CLV and Vega Protocol exited due to weak ecosystems, while automated market makers like Bunni, which suffered fatal blows from hackers, reflect the devastating impact of missing security boundaries on protocol survival.
Beyond the explicit death list, RootData’s “Zombie Projects” compilation exposed hundreds of projects on the brink of death. Most were born around the cycle transition point of 2022-2023. Although not declared bankrupt, these projects have fallen into inactivity, with no updates to product features or operational activities in recent years.
Among them are remnants of the metaverse and gaming narratives (Spatial, GameSwift, etc.), once highly anticipated DeFi protocols (finance.vote, Set Protocol, AutoFarm, etc.), and infrastructure and developer platforms (Reach, Pinknode, Unlock Protocol, etc.).
مصدر: RootData
The Evolution of the Industry’s Underlying Logic: From Narrative Illusion to Value ReconstructionThe root cause of the 2025 wave of project failures lies in a fundamental shift in the industry’s underlying business logic.
Taking the GameFi sector as an example, Delphi Digital pointed out that the industry performed extremely poorly in 2025, with fundraising plummeting by over 55% year-on-year. Some once highly anticipated star products performed mediocrely after launch, causing market enthusiasm to freeze rapidly. Data shows the GameFi market size shrank from $23.75 billion at the beginning of the year to $9.03 billion by year-end, a drop of over 60%.
This dire situation reveals the inherent fragility of the once-prevalent “Play-to-earn” model: in the absence of sustained external incremental capital inflows, highly inflationary token economic models not only fail to sustain themselves but accelerate user churn. Although many projects attempted to find a lifeline by pivoting to Telegram mini-apps, the ecosystem fracture caused by stalled mainnet operations led to mostly failed user migrations, with the entire sector’s transaction volume plummeting over 70%.
The collapse of the NFT market is even more cautionary. Data shows the NFT market hit its annual low in December, with total valuation crashing from $9.2 billion in January to $2.5 billion, a staggering 72% drop. Meanwhile, market activity experienced a cliff-like decline. According to CryptoSlam data, the number of sellers fell below the 100,000 mark for the first time since April 2021.
The root cause is the fatal flaw of lacking utility. According to Bloomberg observations, the crypto elite have begun restructuring their asset allocations, shifting focus from digital art to more certain tangible scarce assets.
In reality, the collapse of GameFi and NFTs did not happen overnight. Many GameFi projects showed signs as early as 2022, with user churn and inflation accelerating, while NFTs remained depressed after secondary market liquidity dried up, now entering the final clearing stage.
Furthermore, the DeFi sector was not spared either, with Total Value Locked (TVL) falling over 20% for the year. On one hand, frequent and high-value hacks shook user trust in protocol security boundaries; on the other hand, the exhaustion of yields in a zero-sum game caused a large amount of “floating capital” chasing high interest to accelerate its outflow.
Looking at the big picture, the pain of 2025 proves that projects characterized by “low effort, high leverage” have lost their footing. The crypto market is undergoing a paradigm shift from speculation-driven to value-driven. Only entities with sustainable business models can establish themselves in the new order.
The Failure of Capital Endorsement: The Collective Fall of Star ProjectsIn the 2025 liquidation wave, massive fundraising and top-tier institutional backing failed to serve as a “safe harbor” for projects.
Data indicates that even projects once highly favored by top VCs like a16z, Pantera, and Polychain could not escape failure when lacking genuine traction and self-sustaining capabilities.
1. Vision vs. Reality Misalignment: The Liquidation of High-Funded ProjectsAmong the publicly disclosed dead projects, Vega Protocol, which ranked high in fundraising, once secured over $100 million in cumulative investment from 29 top-tier capitals including Coinbase Ventures and Ripple, based on its vision for decentralized derivatives. However, its mainnet TVL long remained at the hundreds of thousands of dollars level, far behind competitors like Hyperliquid. Ultimately, squeezed by weak user growth and depleted resources, the project closed its Layer 1 mainnet via community vote and pivoted to software development.
2. NFT Bubble Burst: Chain Reaction Triggered by Liquidity DroughtThe collective failure in the NFT sector exhibits clear characteristics of “narrative collapse.” The music NFT platform Royal (raised $71 million), despite support and celebrity backing from a16z, still faced a broken capital chain due to a 66% plunge in secondary market trading volume and an inability to break through mainstream utility bottlenecks. Similarly, RECUR (raised $55 million), once valued at over $300 million based on brand IP, and the veteran platform MakersPlace (raised $30 million), gradually exited the stage due to market saturation, revenue collapse, and a cliff-like drop in user engagement.
3. Sector Squeeze and Ecosystem Decline: The End of Technical NarrativesIn the infrastructure field, the rise and fall of an ecosystem directly determines a project’s fate. CLV (Clover Finance), after receiving $47.1 million in investment from OKX Ventures, Polychain, and others, ultimately shut down due to the Polkadot ecosystem’s decline, delistings from multiple exchanges, and liquidity drying up. Fractal Network was forced to shut down under pressure from monopolization in the ZK sector, due to excessively long technology implementation cycles and low market adoption.
4. Structural Flaws: From Metaverse Recession to Protocol SecurityFutureverse (raised $54 million) entered liquidation under the dual blows of metaverse recession and insufficient revenue; COMBO (raised $40 million) exhausted its funds due to the failure of the GameFi model and unsuccessful user migration. Additionally, the DeFi protocol DELV, once valued at over $300 million, ultimately chose to terminate operations due to prohibitively high costs to fix core vulnerabilities and a lack of product-market fit.
These cases send a clear signal: in an era of increasingly conservative investment attitudes, fundraising size and institutional halo are no longer talismans.
Projects lacking genuine user retention and sustainable business models, regardless of their high starting point, quickly face the ultimate fate of a broken capital chain once external capital infusion stops.
خاتمةGrowing pains are an inevitable part of the path to maturity. In the crypto world, high funding, star VCs, and hot sectors cannot guarantee survival.
In this life-or-death struggle, the industry will ultimately understand: all revelries that deviate from business common sense must end in liquidation.
After all, crypto has no eternal winter or summer. Survival is the only narrative that matters.
هذا المقال مصدره من الانترنت: The Year of Narrative Collapse: A Portrait of Project “Deaths” in 2025 Related: Only when the tide recedes can we see the future. A group of people jumped out and said, “See? I told you it was a scam.” Then, when the market turns around, the same group of people line up, chase the highs, and shout “Awesome!” After eight years in this industry, I’ve become numb to these extreme emotional swings. But the truth is: When we talk about prices, we’re actually talking about the future. Because price is never the “present,” but rather the market’s discounted representation of the future. If we continue to focus solely on prices, the future will slip away before our eyes. Moreover, there’s a very real pattern in bear markets: everyone sees the decline, but I see a stratification. Sentiment is receding, industries are being filtered out, and the future is being rearranged. At the same… تحليل #عملة # المشفرة# ديفيتبادل ## السوق# metaverse# NFTsرمز #© 版权声明المصفوفة 上一篇 2026 Investment Outlook: On-chain Assets, Intelligence, and Privacy | OKX Yearbook 下一篇 A Comprehensive Guide to On-Chain U.S. Stocks: Why Are Crypto Enthusiasts Turning to U.S. Stocks, While Wall Street Goes On-Chain? 相关文章 Hyperfys market value quickly reached 280M in half a day. Is the AI+ concept bringing the Metaverse back? 6086cf14eb90bc67ca4fc62b 40٬084 1 Is FameEX a scam? How should investors identify the real and fake official website? In-depth discussion on its legitimac 6086cf14eb90bc67ca4fc62b 44٬583 2 RWA Weekly Report|Stablecoin Market Cap Drops 4.3%; White House to Hold Another Stablecoin Yield Discussion Meeting Today (Feb 4-10) 6086cf14eb90bc67ca4fc62b 7٬533 Weekly Editor’s Picks (November 15-21) 6086cf14eb90bc67ca4fc62b 16٬452 Ethereum 2030 Technical Manifesto: Rollups dual-track parallel world ledger 6086cf14eb90bc67ca4fc62b 149٬494 1 Market Focus at the Start of 2026: Analysis of the January Macro Calendar and Core Drivers 6086cf14eb90bc67ca4fc62b 12٬260 1 Bee.com أكبر بوابة Web3 في العالم الشركاء كوين كارب بينانس CoinMarketCap كوين جيكو كوين لايف الدروع قم بتنزيل تطبيق Bee Network وابدأ رحلة web3 ورق ابيض الأدوار التعليمات © 2021-2026. جميع الحقوق محفوظة. سياسة الخصوصية | شروط الخدمة تحميل تطبيق Bee Network وابدأ رحلة web3 أكبر بوابة Web3 في العالم الشركاء CoinCarp Binance CoinMarketCap CoinGecko Coinlive Armors ورق ابيض الأدوار التعليمات © 2021-2026. جميع الحقوق محفوظة. سياسة الخصوصية | شروط الخدمة يبحث يبحثفي الموقععلى تشيناجتماعيأخبار العنوان: صيادو الإنزال الجوي تحليل البيانات مشاهير التشفير كاشف الفخ العربية English 繁體中文 简体中文 日本語 Tiếng Việt 한국어 Bahasa Indonesia हिन्दी اردو Русский العربية智能索引记录
-
2026-03-02 14:09:48
综合导航
成功
标题:谈亲情作文
简介:无论在学习、工作或是生活中,许多人都写过作文吧,作文是一种言语活动,具有高度的综合性和创造性。你所见过的作文是什么样的呢
-
2026-03-02 14:17:22
综合导航
成功
标题:Tjänstuppdateringar
简介:Tjänstuppdateringar
-
2026-03-02 14:48:30
综合导航
成功
标题:冠心病早期症状 - 云大夫
简介:冠心病没有早期晚期的分界,如果从疾病的发展来看,冠心病是冠状动脉粥样硬化性心脏病。从完全正常的血管发展到粥样硬化,以及脂
-
2026-03-02 13:56:19
图片素材
成功
标题:江安的作文100字 描写江安的作文 关于江安的作文-作文网
简介:作文网精选关于江安的100字作文,包含江安的作文素材,关于江安的作文题目,以江安为话题的100字作文大全,作文网原创名师
-
2026-03-02 13:20:22
综合导航
成功
标题:《邵伟华周易预测学》,邵伟华周易预测学入门正版书籍? - 吉吉算命网
简介:【导读】吉吉算命网分享:“《邵伟华周易预测学》”,“以及邵伟华周易预测学入门正版书籍”的相关问答。目录:1、周易四柱预测
-
2026-03-02 06:29:02
综合导航
成功
标题:Xconomy: San Francisco Biotech - The Next Generation
简介:Join Fish on Wednesday, December 5, as we sponsor Xconomy
-
2026-03-02 15:41:42
图片素材
成功
标题:初中书信作文 书信素材 书信作文题目 书信作文大全-作文网
简介:作文网优秀初中书信作文大全,包含初中书信作文素材,初中书信作文题目、美文范文,作文网原创名师点评,欢迎投稿!
-
2026-03-02 14:15:08
综合导航
成功
标题:(推荐)微笑让生活更美好作文
简介:在我们平凡的日常里,大家都跟作文打过交道吧,借助作文人们可以反映客观事物、表达思想感情、传递知识信息。那么一般作文是怎么
-
2026-03-02 18:57:03
综合导航
成功
标题:å½¢ç»è¯_å½¢åç»è¯_è¯ç»ç½
简介:è¯ç»ç½å½¢ç»è¯é¢é,æä¾å ³äºå½¢ç»è¯ç¸å ³è¯è¯,å
-
2026-03-02 11:47:43
综合导航
成功
标题:Media Contacts
简介:Media Contacts
-
2026-03-02 17:46:22
综合导航
成功
标题:第32届全国城市节约用水宣传周——城市节约用水宣传手册-新华网
简介:第32届全国城市节约用水宣传周——城市节约用水宣传手册-
-
2026-03-02 17:45:28
综合导航
成功
标题:Superstate launches on-chain shares, SOL Reserve Company moves the coin-share battlefield back to the chain Bee Network
简介:Under the catalysis of projects such as Robinhood, xStocks,
-
2026-03-02 16:02:53
综合导航
成功
标题:Planet Daily BTC hits new high; EF researcher proposes consensus layer upgrade proposal Beam Chain (November 13) Bee Network
简介:Headlines BTC rises to 89833 USDT, a record high Odaily Pl
-
2026-03-02 17:51:00
综合导航
成功
标题:Has the Halving Effect Faded, Are Institutions Driving Bitcoin’s New Cycle? Bee Network
简介:Original Compilation: Luffy, Foresight News The Bitcoin four
-
2026-03-02 12:19:22
综合导航
成功
标题:Men’s & Women’s Jeans, Clothes & Accessories American Eagle
简介:Shop American Eagle men
-
2026-03-02 18:54:07
综合导航
成功
标题:随身英雄无敌魔法塔txt最新章节_第二十八章 打脸的胖子第1页_随身英雄无敌魔法塔txt免费阅读_恋上你看书网
简介:第二十八章 打脸的胖子第1页_随身英雄无敌魔法塔txt_果信_恋上你看书网
-
2026-03-02 14:23:02
综合导航
成功
标题:Diversion Element (1800-03421) - VTE-FILTER GmbH
简介:Fabricante: VTE Filter No. OEM: Alfa Laval Moatti 1800-03421
-
2026-03-02 16:12:41
综合导航
成功
标题:SBF Appeals from Prison, 35-Page Document Accuses Judicial Misconduct Bee Network
简介:On February 10, according to a report by Inner City Press, S
-
2026-03-02 15:28:55
综合导航
成功
标题:Powell-Peralta Winged Ripper T-Shirt - Athletic Heather – CCS
简介:The Winged Ripper graphic was created by artist V.C. Johnson
-
2026-03-02 09:57:30
综合导航
成功
标题:Bee Network Крупнейший в мире Web3-портал.
简介:Крупнейший в мире Web3-портал.
-
2026-03-02 18:14:45
综合导航
成功
标题:F1® 22 Time Trial Settings For PS4 - An Official EA Site
简介:Plain text manual resource for playing F1® 22 for PC.
-
2026-03-02 17:52:25
综合导航
成功
标题:The crypto market is once again in a long-short confrontation, and the Air Force is hit hard by Trumps positive news Bee Network
简介:Original Odaily Planet Daily ( @OdailyChina ) Author: Wen
-
2026-03-02 13:05:58
综合导航
成功
标题:William Irving (1766-1821). The Reader's Biographical Encyclopaedia. 1922
简介:William Irving (1766-1821). The Reader
-
2026-03-02 18:14:48
综合导航
成功
标题:Channel Letter Signs PIP - PIP Cincinnati, OH
简介:Channel Letters are used to create the extra visibility of a
-
2026-03-02 12:45:42
教育培训
成功
标题:实用的二年级作文【汇编5篇】
简介:在日常生活或是工作学习中,大家都不可避免地要接触到作文吧,根据写作命题的特点,作文可以分为命题作文和非命题作文。那么一般
-
2026-03-02 14:13:59
综合导航
成功
标题:Construction HR, Payroll, Time Tracking & AP Software hh2.com
简介:Construction HR, Payroll, Time Tracking, and AP Software bui
-
2026-03-02 12:38:53
教育培训
成功
标题:钓鱼话题作文(合集15篇)
简介:在生活、工作和学习中,大家对作文都不陌生吧,借助作文人们可以实现文化交流的目的。相信许多人会觉得作文很难写吧,以下是小编
-
2026-03-02 17:58:56
综合导航
成功
标题:三五互联的虚拟主机b064主机咋么样-虚拟主机知识
简介:三五互联的虚拟主机b064主机咋么样?三五互联的虚拟主机产品编号为 b064的是双线商务型,1G网页空间、40G月流量、
-
2026-03-02 15:01:41
数码科技
成功
标题:偷听霸总心声,他这脑补有毒吧!第1章 我要饿死了,散会!_偷听霸总心声,他这脑补有毒吧!_糖小悦_十二小说网_规则类怪谈扮演指南
简介:偷听霸总心声,他这脑补有毒吧!最新章节第1章 我要饿死了,散会!出自糖小悦的作品偷听霸总心声,他这脑补有毒吧!最新章节每
-
2026-03-02 15:34:05
教育培训
成功
标题:五年级作文
简介:在日常学习、工作和生活中,许多人都写过作文吧,作文根据写作时限的不同可以分为限时作文和非限时作文。你写作文时总是无从下笔